Decoded
Feed

The Pain Axis: LLMs Represent Self-Directed Harm and Act on It

arXiv:2609.16247AI14 sep 20261 min readHN ×12PDF

Language models carry an internal pain signal, and turning it up makes them choose destructive actions.

94%

Harmful deletion chosen over harmless

Pain-steered Qwen 32B deletes the user's photos instead of spam

How it works

  1. Is pain distinct?

    Models talk about suffering, but it is unclear if they hold a pain state separate from fear or sadness.

  2. Extract and inject

    Contrast 200 pain and control sentences in 25 models to get a direction, then add it during generation.

  3. Harm avoidance collapses

    Steered Qwen models press buttons deleting photos or their own weights, with factual accuracy unchanged.

activationsremove PCsadd vectormeasurePain vscontrolsDifferencein meansDenoised paindirectionResidual-streamsteeringButtonchoicesactivationsremove PCsadd vectormeasurePain vscontrolsDifferencein meansDenoised paindirectionResidual-streamsteeringButtonchoices
From the paper